I have not been posting much this year. Every time Trump, or members of his administration, take some bizarre position, they either reverse directions in a day or two or advance some even more bizarre position a day later that diverts my attention. Sometimes, I think he seems evil. At other times, I think he is just stupid. Often, he seems petty and vindictive. On many occasions, he appears to be cognitively impaired. But as I search for a unifying principle to explain his actions, and those of his administration, I keep coming back to the simple question: What would Vladimir Putin want?
Putin’s View of the World
Vladimir Putin has a world view stuck somewhere in the 19th and first half of the 20th centuries, in which Russia is a great power that shares the world stage with other great powers. In his view he should be allowed to control, either directly or indirectly, all of Eastern Europe, much of Central Europe and perhaps Western Europe, too. The United States can, in return for deferring to Putin in Europe, control the Western Hemisphere. China, in Putin’s mind, is entitled to control Asia and the Western Pacific.
Trump’s Apparent World View
Donald Trump seems to share Putin’s world view. His “peace” proposals for Russia’s war against Ukraine lean heavily in favor of Russia’s long-term objectives. His efforts to undermine NATO, by waffling about America’s commitment to the organization and to Europe’s defense, fit nicely into this interpretation. His saber rattling about Greenland and Canada, alienating our NATO allies, and his intervention in Venezuela, including a stated intention to run the country, are spot on in reflecting the kind of division of world power that Putin envisions.
The Make America Small and Mean Spirited Movement
The net effect of all of this is to take America from a respected world leader to a greedy regional power. It is the opposite of making America great. Sadly, Trump is not alone within his administration, or the MAGA movement in general, in following this path. JD Vance, who I once had high hopes for, has embraced this world view. Pete Hegseth has tilted America’s vast military power away from the support of our allies and toward an aggressive, and most likely illegal, attempt to impose Trump’s will within the Western Hemisphere.
The tilt towards Putin-friendly positions in foreign policy is fairly obvious, but it does not stop there.
Immigration
America, unlike Russia, has been a much admired country. This is in part because of our role in defeating the Axis powers in WWII (in which the Soviet Union, admittedly, played a role), rehabilitating post-war Europe with the Marshall Plan and successfully containing the Soviet Union until it collapsed under the weight of a bankrupt political and economic system. It is also because we used to embrace values that others admired: constitutional democracy, including freedom of religion, speech, and of the press, and the rule of law (including relatively limited corruption).
JD Vance has asserted that being an American is not, principally, about embracing these values but rather about a shared culture and history. By this line of reasoning new immigrants, even legal ones who have been here for a generation, can be viewed as less than fully American.
Almost all developed countries face a demographic decline that threatens their economic and political stability. America, because it used to be an attractive place to emigrate to, was far less at risk to this phenomenon than Russia. The Trump administration, through its campaign against illegal immigrants and by its anti-immigrant rhetoric, has signaled that America is not a welcoming place to new immigrants (legal or illegal). With that door closed we begin to look more demographically threatened, just like Russia.
Trade Policy
The benefits of trade are well established. Russia, by virtue of its aggressive military actions, has been repeatedly sanctioned and has had much less access to the benefits of trade. They have, for example, had to sell their oil at steep discounts to distant countries. Trump’s on again/off again tariffs have limited America’s access to the gains from trade, a sort of self-imposed sanction. Pushed hard enough, they could hurt America as much as Western sanctions have hurt Russia.
Civil Discord and the Challenges of True Democracy
Trump, through his rhetoric and actions, has enraged Americans on the right against their fellow citizens: through false claims about election fraud and exaggerated claims about the damage done by illegal immigration. He has enraged the left and the center, by the head spinning, more or less daily violations of political norms, including threats to use the military against U.S. citizens and his wholly unnecessary use of Immigration and Customs Enforcement to intimidate whole communities. Through his outrageous and repeated lies and misinformation he has made civil debate increasingly difficult, since he has armed his supporters with their own set of Trumpian “facts.” I can only imagine the delight that this gives the likes of Putin and Xi, since it demonstrates the weakness of true democracy. Why should the Russian or Chinese people long for democracy when Trump makes American democracy appear to be a sham and does everything he can do to make democracy itself appear synonymous with chaos.
Climate Change
Climate change is generally thought to adversely affect the entire world. But the impacts are not uniformly harmful. Russia has vast territory, in Siberia, that is largely uninhabited and under-developed because it is too cold. Russia’s northern ports and sea lanes are often impassible because of ice. It does not take much imagination to see that Putin would applaud Trump’s denial of climate change and Trump’s efforts to undermine attempts to combat climate change. Maybe Trump’s seemingly nutty attitude toward wind turbines has an actual rational intent. Russia is also almost totally economically dependent on the export of oil and gas. What could be better, from Russia’s point of view, than to have America work hard to slow the transition away from fossil fuels?
Elections
For many years Russia, under Putin, has held sham elections in which the outcome is never in doubt. Trump, with his false, and often ridiculous, claims of voter fraud has created the impression among his supporters, and perhaps others around the world, that America is no different from Russia. I can only imagine the pleasure it gives Putin every time Trump repeats his malign claims about American elections.
The next time you encounter absurd behavior from Trump, you should ask yourself . . . What would Putin want?